
The government’s climate advisers have warned ministers that relaxing Britain’s electric car sales targets would put the UK’s legal climate commitments at risk and leave households more exposed to volatile fuel prices.
In a letter to Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander published on Wednesday 18 November, Climate Change Committee (CCC) chair Nigel Topping said the zero emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate was “working effectively”. The committee warned that weakening it would miss an opportunity to cut costs for a typical household by around £800 a year and could raise UK oil use by up to 15 million barrels a year by 2030. The intervention had been trailed by the Guardian earlier in the week.
What the mandate requires
Under the current rules, 80 per cent of new cars sold must be zero emission from 2030, rising to 100 per cent from 2035. The Department for Transport is consulting on changes, and there have been reports that ministers are prepared to reduce the targets. The Daily Mail says the government is widely expected to ease them from the start of next year.
A government spokesperson said: “We remain committed to the phase out of all new cars relying solely on petrol and diesel engines by 2030, and to 100% of new car and van sales being zero emission by 2035, and our legally binding net zero targets.”
Mr Topping said: “Weakening the Zero Emission Vehicle Mandate would miss an opportunity to reduce the cost of living for people, undermine Britain’s competitiveness, and leave us more exposed to volatile fossil fuel prices.” The committee also warned, the BBC reports, that the UK would be likely to miss legally binding climate targets if the mandate were cut.
Industry and campaigners divided
Carmakers argue the targets are too demanding and that they are having to discount electric models heavily to sell enough of them. Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, said manufacturers were investing billions but demand remained below the required levels. “Regulation mustn’t undermine UK competitiveness or hold back the transition,” he said, calling for “fundamental change to the targets” alongside more support for buyers.
Environmental groups take the opposite view. Ami McCarthy, head of politics at Greenpeace UK, said: “Watering down the current sales targets for EVs would be like driving with the handbrake on.” Campaigners point out that the UK is currently exceeding its sales target and that sales of battery electric cars rose by half last month compared with the same month a year earlier.
Uncertainty already affecting buyers
There are signs the review itself is influencing decisions on the forecourt. Annual research commissioned by Kwik Fit, reported by Garage Matters, found that 30 per cent of motorists planning to make their next car electric said the consultation had made them less likely to do so. A quarter of existing EV drivers said the same about choosing another battery electric model.
Drivers are split on the targets themselves: 36 per cent support the current timetable and 29 per cent oppose it, while among current EV owners support rises to 56 per cent. Some 7 per cent of drivers own a fully electric car today, but 18 per cent say their next one will be.
Dan Joyce, operations director at Kwik Fit, said: “It is vital that the ZEV Mandate phasing treads the right balance between encouraging the transition to low emissions and the practicalities vehicle manufacturers face. However, it’s notable that any potential changes have a clear risk of creating uncertainty among drivers.”
What it means for Manchester readers
For anyone in Greater Manchester weighing up a new car, the outcome will shape prices and choice. Manufacturers that no longer need to hit tough targets may have less reason to discount electric models, while a looser mandate could mean petrol and hybrid cars stay on sale in larger numbers for longer.
The decision also matters for the region’s air quality ambitions and for local garages, which the Kwik Fit research suggests will be servicing a mix of petrol, hybrid and electric cars for years to come. Practical barriers remain significant: the same study found range anxiety and the inability to charge at home were each cited by 35 per cent of drivers.
What happens next
With the CCC’s letter now on the table, ministers must decide how far, if at all, to change the mandate. Government sources insist no decision has been taken, but having been told plainly by their own advisers not to weaken the targets, ministers will face a harder task justifying any retreat.

